How the math works
How the page works
Pick an item and it starts at a typical price, or type any name and its price. The answer shows at once as a Cost Facts label: the full cost over the years you keep it, that cost a month on average, what the money could grow to instead, and every cost behind it with its share of the bill. Nothing to answer first.
Every figure can be changed where it stands: each cost, how you pay (Cash, Loan, Balloon loan or Lease) and its terms, resale, uses a year, the years you keep it, the years the money grows, growth a year and inflation. × removes a row, and a + button brings back the item’s own rows. “+ Add a cost” and “+ Add a saving” add rows of your own: once, a month or a year. Savings come off the full cost; “pays for itself” under Words on the page says how the page counts them. Each change updates the page at once, and the link carries all of it.
The score is optional: three quick questions under the numbers. How you pay comes from the costs, so it is not asked. A page gets a score only when every question is answered; until then it shows numbers only.
A page someone sends you shows their numbers, as they sent them. Change any figure and the page becomes yours, with only that figure changed; their link stays as it was.
The big numbers
The big numbers are the full cost (everything you pay over the years you keep it, less savings and what it sells for) and that cost a month on average. The line under them is what the money could grow to if it were invested instead of spent. For that line, each payment counts from the day it is paid: the price (or the down payment and each loan payment), any one-time cost, and each year’s running costs, counted in the middle of that year. Each one grows at the return rate until the end of the period, and savings and what it sells for come off, grown the same way. When savings outweigh the rest, the result goes below zero and the line says how far ahead buying it puts you.
Invested instead, in 25 years: each item at its typical figures, at each preset return rate, in today's dollars
| Item | Price | Careful (3%) | Stocks (5%) | Optimist (7%) | In future dollars, at 5% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| e-bike | $1,737 | $4,100 | $6,700 | $10,700 | $11,700 |
| car | $50,089 | $161,000 | $250,000 | $386,000 | $441,000 |
| new phone | $1,089 | $1,700 | $2,800 | $4,600 | $5,000 |
The return rate
I assume 5% a year after inflation. That is a choice, below what stocks returned over the long run; the source is below.
You can also give a return before inflation, the figure funds and banks usually quote. The page turns it into one after inflation the exact way, not by subtracting: one plus the return, divided by one plus inflation, minus one. At 2.3% inflation, 7.41% before inflation is 5% after it. Change inflation and the figure after inflation follows.
- Return after inflation 5%ubs.com ·
Inflation and loans
Loan payments are fixed dollar amounts, so each one is turned into today's dollars first: divided by one plus inflation, once for every year since the loan started. A balance still left at the end of the period counts the same way.
A cheap loan, like 0%, can cost less than paying cash. That is true, and I hate it.
Future dollars
Every number is in today's dollars: what the money buys now. The small line under the headline shows the same amount in future dollars, the dollars on a statement in that year: the headline, grown by inflation once for each year. Example: $6,700 today is about $11,700 in future dollars in 25 years, at 2.3% inflation.
Tax
We assume tax-free growth, as in a Roth IRA or 401(k). In a normal taxable account, expect about 15–20% less.
Prices include sales tax. I don't add it on top.
Resale
Resale values come from cited curves, one per vehicle class or per item. They are front-loaded: the biggest drop comes in the first year. Between two points of a curve the value follows a straight line. Past the last point it keeps falling at the last segment's yearly rate. You can type your own resale in dollars or as a percent of the price, and the other is worked out from it. Your own figure stays when the years kept change, while a typical one follows the curve. Typed in dollars, it stays put when the price changes; typed as a percent, it moves with the price. Without a curve, nothing comes back until you type a resale.
The bill
The bill shows whole dollars, and its total is the sum of the rows as shown, so you can add it up yourself: $1,940 for the e-bike. The % of the bill is each row’s share of the full cost, rounded so the shares add up exactly. Figures that look years ahead (the headline, future dollars, what each deal keeps) are guesses, so they are rounded: the bigger, the rounder. The cheaper-choice line under the full cost is plain dollars over the same years as the bill, rounded the same way.
“A month on average” is the full cost divided by the months you keep it. The line under it says what actually leaves your account: the price or the down payment now, then each month the loan payment plus the running costs, then the running costs alone.
The score
The score adds up the parts below, each rounded to a whole number first. Their ranges come from the score settings. The total never goes below the bottom of the scale or above its top: when the parts add up past either end, one more row, “Off the scale, capped”, brings them back to the score.
- the price, measured in savings: +2 to +25 points
- how much it's wanted: 0 to +20 points
- the reasons given: −20 to +35 points
- how it's paid for: 0 to +15 points
- costs on top of the price: 0 to +10 points
- a used one costs less: 0 to +10 points
- a price above the typical one: 0 to +10 points
The score never depends on who pays us.
Choices, not facts
Some numbers on the page are my choices, not facts with a source. Each one is a field you can change on the page.
- The money grows for 25 years. Change it under “Money grows for” in Assumptions.
- Cost per use counts how often each thing gets used in a year:
- e-bike: 150 uses a year
- car: 300 uses a year
- new phone: 365 uses a year
- anything else: 0 uses a year
- The ideas listed under what else the price could fund use rough typical price ranges, not researched figures. The site picks them to fit the price; it doesn't promise a return.
What was checked
Checked by nobody, honestly: one AI agent found each number, a second one opened the source and checked it, and a human signed off on it. The math has automated tests. The sources are below, with their dates.
Rough figures
Some numbers are rough, or older than I'd like. Each is the best source available, and each is labeled in the list of sources too.
- Resale value, e-bike Rough figure
- How long people keep one, e-bike Rough figure Newest available: older than I'd like
- Charging, e-bike Newest available: older than I'd like
- Price saved, e-bike, used Newest available: older than I'd like
- Typical price, e-bike Rough figure Newest available: older than I'd like
- How long people keep one, car Newest available: older than I'd like
- Gas, car Newest available: older than I'd like
- Price saved, car, three years old Newest available: older than I'd like
- Typical price, new phone Rough figure
- How long people keep one, anything else Rough figure Newest available: older than I'd like
No source yet, so these are left out:
- Parking
Words on the page
- Full cost
- Everything paid while it's kept (price, loan interest, running and one-time costs), minus savings and what it sells for at the end. Example: a $30,000 price, $20,000 to run for 8 years, sold for $10,000 at the end: a full cost of $40,000. It is a plain sum of the dollars as paid, with no inflation and no growth. A lease you hand back has nothing to sell, so everything paid on it counts.
- A month on average
- The full cost spread evenly over the months you keep it. $40,000 over 8 years (96 months) is about $417 a month. It is an average, not a bill. What actually leaves your account is the line under it: what you pay up front, then each month the payment plus running costs, then running costs alone. Resale lowers the average, though you only get that money back at the end.
- Up front
- Paid on day one: the price in cash, or the down payment (on a lease, due at signing), plus one-time costs, minus one-time savings. After that the line shows what leaves your account each month: the payment plus running costs while the loan or lease runs, then running costs alone. Unlike a month on average, these are the amounts you actually pay, in the order you pay them. Where savings are bigger, the line says what comes back instead.
- Running costs
- What it costs to have and use it each year, apart from the price: for a car, insurance, gas, service and registration. Each one comes from a cited source and is a field under Where the money goes: change it, remove it with ×, or add your own with + Add a cost. Each counts the same amount for every year you keep it. Savings added with + Add a saving come off them.
- Invested instead
- What the money it costs could grow to if invested instead. $10,000 growing 5% a year above inflation for 25 years becomes about $33,900. Each payment grows from when it is paid to the end of Money grows for: price or down payment, loan payments, one-time and running costs. Savings and resale come off. If the period ends before the years kept, what is owed is paid and an owned one sold. Today's dollars: later loan payments count less than in the full cost.
- Ahead
- How much more one choice, often not buying, leaves you with at the end than the other, with the difference invested. Behind means less. Both choices are counted over the same years kept and grown at the same rate to the end of Money grows for, in today's dollars. Where savings outweigh what it costs, buying it comes out ahead. Example: $5,000 less up front, invested at 5% a year for 25 years, is about $16,900 ahead.
- Today's dollars
- Amounts shown as what money buys now, so figures years apart compare fairly. $100,000 in 25 years means what $100,000 buys today. The account itself would show more, because prices rise. At 2.3% inflation, $100,000 in today's dollars is about $177,000 on a statement in 25 years. Those are future dollars.
- Future dollars
- The dollars a statement shows in that year: today's dollars plus inflation. At 2% a year, $100 today is about $164 in 25 years. The page counts in today's dollars so that years far apart compare fairly. Future dollars are shown once, under the by-year table, so the number on a statement years from now isn't a surprise.
- Before tax
- No tax is taken off the growth, as in a tax-free retirement account. In a taxable account the result would be lower. The page doesn't know your tax situation, so it leaves tax on the growth out. Sales tax is in a typical price only where its source says so; a car's purchase taxes are in its Registration and taxes row.
- Above inflation
- What invested money gains a year in buying power, after rising prices are taken out. 7.1% growth with 2% inflation is 5% above inflation. This is the rate the page grows money at. The default is a choice, below what stocks returned over the long run; its source is under the field. Type any rate, or switch to Inflation included to type the rate a fund or bank quotes.
- Inflation included
- A growth rate as funds and banks usually quote it, before rising prices are taken out. With 2% inflation, 7.1% included is 5% above. The page turns it into a rate above inflation the exact way, not by subtracting: (1 + rate) ÷ (1 + inflation) − 1. Change inflation and the rate above inflation follows.
- Inflation
- How fast prices rise each year. At 2% a year, what costs $100 today costs about $122 in 10 years. The page uses it to turn loan payments, which are fixed dollar amounts, into today's dollars, and to show future dollars. The default is a forecast of average yearly inflation over the next 10 years; its source is under the field.
- Money grows for
- How long the money in Invested instead keeps growing, counted from today. It can run past the years you keep it. Pick a number of years, or an age to grow it until. The default is a choice, not a fact, and every figure that says ahead or invested uses this same period.
- Keep it
- How many years you own it before selling or replacing it. The full cost and a month on average cover these years. The default is how long owners typically keep one, from a cited source. A typical resale follows it: keep it longer and less comes back. On a lease you hand back, it follows the lease's length. Tick Buy a new one every N years to count replacing it again and again.
- APR
- The yearly interest rate on the loan, as lenders quote it. At 7% APR, owing $10,000 for a whole year costs about $700 in interest. APR stands for annual percentage rate. It can include some lender fees, so it may sit a little above the bare interest rate. The page works out the monthly payment from it; type the monthly payment instead and the page works out the rate.
- Loan interest
- What the loan adds to the price: every payment added up, minus what was borrowed. 48 payments of $500 on $20,000 borrowed: $4,000 interest. Plain dollars, as paid. The bill counts all of the loan's interest, even when the loan runs longer than the years you keep it.
- Down payment
- The part of the price you pay at the start; the loan covers the rest. 10% down on $40,000: you pay $4,000 and borrow $36,000. A bigger down payment means a smaller loan, so less interest and lower monthly payments. The money paid down still counts in Invested instead, from the day it is paid.
- Due at signing
- What a lease asks for the day you sign: usually the first monthly payment, fees and any down payment. It counts in the full cost. Type the amount from the offer or contract. When it is at least one monthly payment, the page takes the first payment as part of it and counts one payment fewer after it. A refundable deposit comes back, so leave it out.
- Balloon
- Lower monthly payments, then one big last payment: the balloon. Pay it to keep the item; some contracts let you hand the item back instead. Paid, the item is yours and its resale counts. Handed back, the balloon isn't paid and nothing comes back to sell.
- Buyout price
- What the lease contract says you can pay at the end to keep it. Left empty, the item goes back when the lease ends. With a buyout you own it, so its resale counts. Without one, nothing comes back to sell, and the years you keep it follow the lease's length.
- Fees at the end
- What a lease charges when it ends, such as a return fee or charges for extra wear or use. Type what the contract says. The page counts them in the last month of the lease. Leave the field empty if the contract has none.
- Lease
- Monthly payments to use something for a set time; at the end you hand it back, or buy it for the buyout price. Handed back, you own nothing at the end, so there is no resale: the full cost is everything paid on the lease plus running costs. Bought out, it counts like a purchase, and what the lease adds above the price shows as its own row.
- What the lease adds
- Everything paid on the lease, buyout included, minus the item's price. It counts in the full cost, like loan interest.
- Resale
- What it sells for when you're done, which comes off the full cost: $20,000 back on a $50,000 price, or 40%. Typical values come from cited resale curves for each item or vehicle class. The biggest drop comes in the first year, so keeping it longer brings less back but spreads the drop over more years. Your own figure stays when the years change; typed in dollars, it also stays when the price changes.
- Cost per use
- The full cost divided by every use. $1,200 over 4 years, used 100 times a year: $3 a use. Uses a year is a rough guess unless you type your own in the field under the row.
- Rough
- Only approximate: the best source is a rough one, or there's no source and it's a guess. Type your own to replace it. Rough figures with a source are listed in How the math works, each with its reason. A guess with no source is labeled as one where it shows.
- Typical
- A researched figure for a typical buyer, with its source and date; the source says which buyers. Type your own and the page uses it. Each typical figure was found by one AI agent, checked against its opened source by a second, and signed off by a human. The date beside a figure is the month it describes. Some are rough or older than ideal, and are labeled so.
- Of savings
- How long it takes to save the price from what's left at month end. Leaving $500 a month, $30,000 takes 5 years. Until you press Use my own pay, it uses typical pay and savings for this country, from a cited source. Your pay stays on this device; a shared link carries only the band, like one to three years.
- Pays for itself
- When what it saves, after its own running costs, has paid back what it cost. Saving $1,500 a year on a $15,000 price: 10 years. What it cost is what is paid for it (the price, or everything paid on the loan or lease) plus one-time costs, in plain dollars. Resale is left out, so the real date may come sooner. When that is past the years it's kept and the full cost is above zero, the page says what the savings pay back meanwhile.
- Saves
- Money it saves or brings in, like a storage unit you stop renting or a rebate. It comes off the full cost.
Sources
- Car insurance $2,098 a yearnewsroom.aaa.com ·
- Car maintenance $1,262 a yearnewsroom.aaa.com ·
- Car registration $802 a yearnewsroom.aaa.com ·
- Distance driven 10,787 mi a yearfhwa.dot.gov ·
- Electricity price $0.18/kWheia.gov ·
- Gas price $4.36/galeia.gov ·
- Typical hours worked 34.2 hours a weekfred.stlouisfed.org ·
- Inflation 2.3%philadelphiafed.org ·
- Typical money left at month end $882.42 a monthfred.stlouisfed.org ·
- Loan rate, new 6.35%experian.com ·
- Loan rate, used 11.19%experian.com ·
- Median age 39.4 yearscensus.gov ·
- Typical take-home pay $7,322.42 a monthfred.stlouisfed.org ·
- Resale value, cars 100% → 58.2% (5 yr) → 34.9% (10 yr)iseecars.com ·
- Resale value, electric cars 100% → 42.8% (5 yr)iseecars.com ·
- Resale value, trucks 100% → 65.8% (5 yr) → 42.8% (10 yr)iseecars.com ·
- Resale value, e-bike 100% → 68% (2 yr) → 44% (4 yr) → 34% (6 yr) → 27% (8 yr) → 19% (11 yr)Rough figurebicyclebluebook.com ·
- How long people keep one, e-bike 10 yearsRough figureNewest available: older than I'd likeapps.bea.gov ·
- Charging, e-bike 14.9 kWh a yearNewest available: older than I'd likeefficiencyvermont.com ·
- Battery wear, e-bike 3.15% of the price a yearradpowerbikes.com ·
- Price saved, e-bike, used 50% of the priceNewest available: older than I'd likeupway.co ·
- Typical price, e-bike $1,737Rough figureNewest available: older than I'd like511.ccta.ca.gov ·
- How long people keep one, car 8.4 yearsNewest available: older than I'd likeiseecars.com ·
- Gas, car 25.6 mpgNewest available: older than I'd likeepa.gov ·
- Typical loan length, car 69 monthsexperian.com ·
- Price saved, car, three years old 31% of the priceNewest available: older than I'd likeiseecars.com ·
- Typical price, car $50,089coxautoinc.com ·
- Resale value, new phone 100% → 71.4% (1 yr) → 51.1% (2 yr) → 37% (3 yr) → 28.5% (4 yr)apple.com ·
- How long people keep one, new phone 3.96 yearsassurant.com ·
- Protection plan, new phone 12.51% of the price a yearapple.com ·
- Price saved, new phone, refurbished 16.69% of the priceapple.com ·
- Price saved, new phone, one model older 11.12% of the priceapple.com ·
- Typical price, new phone $1,089Rough figurecirpapple.substack.com ·
- How long people keep one, anything else 10 yearsRough figureNewest available: older than I'd likeapps.bea.gov ·